Quick Answer
A $15 digital product nets you $13.12 on Etsy (88%) and $13.00 on Gumroad direct (87%), so platform fees barely differ. Clearing $1,000 a month at that price means about 76 sales, or 2.5 every day. AI shrinks the build time but does nothing for demand, which is what actually decides whether you earn.
A $15 digital product nets you $13.12 on Etsy and $13.00 on Gumroad, so the platform matters far less than most guides claim. What matters is that you need roughly 76 sales a month to clear $1,000, which is two and a half a day, every day. AI shrinks the build time for prompt packs, printables, templates and planners from weeks to hours. It does nothing for the demand problem, and demand is what decides whether you earn anything.
Disclosure: some links below are affiliate links. If you sign up through them we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. It never changes our picks. See our affiliate disclosure.
Key takeaways
- Etsy and Gumroad take almost the same cut. On a $15 product: $1.88 to Etsy, $2.00 to Gumroad direct. Verified against both fee policies in September 2026.
- Gumroad's marketplace tier costs 30%, triple its direct rate. If a buyer finds you through Gumroad Discover rather than your own link, your take-home drops from $13.00 to $10.50.
- $1,000 a month means about 76 sales, or 2.5 a day, at a $15 price point. That is the number to plan against, not a revenue goal.
- Etsy Offsite Ads can take another 15% on attributed orders if your shop has made under $10,000 in the past year, cutting a $15 sale to $10.88.
- AI solves the wrong half of the problem. It builds the product fast. Finding 76 buyers a month is the hard part, and no tool shortcuts it.
What are the best digital products to make with AI?
The ones that sell reliably solve a small, specific problem and deliver as a file the buyer downloads instantly.
- Prompt packs: curated ChatGPT or image prompts for one niche, like real estate captions or teacher lesson plans.
- Printables: worksheets, checklists, chore charts, habit trackers.
- Ebooks and guides: short, focused PDFs teaching one skill.
- Notion templates: dashboards and trackers buyers duplicate into their workspace.
- Canva templates: editable social posts, resumes, invoices, presentations.
- AI art prints: wall art and digital downloads.
- Spreadsheets: budget trackers, content calendars, small-business tools.
Start with one format. A tight prompt pack or one well-designed planner beats a store of ten half-finished files. The reason is discoverability: a focused shop ranks for a specific search, a scattered one ranks for nothing.
What do Etsy and Gumroad actually charge?
This is the part most guides get vague about, so here is the arithmetic on a $15 product, verified against both platforms' published fee policies on 21 September 2026.
| Platform | Fees on a $15 sale | You keep |
|---|---|---|
| Etsy | $0.20 listing + 6.5% + payment processing | $13.12 (88%) |
| Gumroad, your own link | 10% + $0.50 | $13.00 (87%) |
| Gumroad Discover | 30% | $10.50 (70%) |
| Etsy with Offsite Ads | above plus 15% attributed | $10.88 (72%) |
Two things fall out of this. First, Etsy and Gumroad direct are within 12 cents of each other. The "Etsy takes too much" argument does not survive the arithmetic at this price point.
Second, the expensive options are the ones where the platform finds your buyer. Gumroad Discover charges 30% and Etsy Offsite Ads charges 15% on attributed orders, because in both cases you are paying for traffic rather than hosting. That is a fair trade, but it needs to be a decision rather than a surprise.
How many sales do you need to make $1,000 a month?
Revenue goals are meaningless without a unit count, and this is the calculation nobody publishes.
At a $15 price point:
| Route | Net per sale | Sales for $1,000 | Per day |
|---|---|---|---|
| Etsy | $13.12 | 76 | 2.5 |
| Gumroad direct | $13.00 | 77 | 2.6 |
| Gumroad Discover | $10.50 | 95 | 3.2 |
Two and a half sales a day, every day, is a useful reality check. It is achievable. It is also considerably more than most new shops manage in their first six months, and it explains why "make $1,000 a day with AI" content is not describing anything real at this price point.
If you want to reach $1,000 with fewer sales, the lever is price, not platform. A $49 product needs 22 sales a month rather than 76. Higher prices demand more substantial products, which is precisely where AI-assisted work has to be genuinely edited rather than generated and listed.
What tools do you actually need?
Four, and most have usable free tiers.
- ChatGPT drafts copy, outlines ebooks, and generates the prompts inside a prompt pack. Treat output as a first draft you edit, never a finished product.
- Canva turns copy into a polished PDF, planner or template. For social templates and carousels sold as packs, PostNitro generates them directly.
- MagicSlides turns an outline into a slide deck, which matters if you sell presentation templates or course material.
- An image generator for artwork and covers. Check the commercial-use terms of whichever you pick, because they differ sharply and some forbid selling output.
- Gumroad or Etsy to host, sell and deliver.
That is the whole starter stack. Add tools later only when a real bottleneck appears.
One warning worth taking seriously: both Etsy and Gumroad prohibit reselling raw, undirected AI output. Etsy requires that you meaningfully direct the work and disclose AI use in the listing. Our guide to selling AI art on Etsy covers the disclosure rules in full.
Why do most AI digital products fail?
Because the product was the easy part, and the seller stopped there.
AI collapses production time. An ebook that took three weeks now takes an afternoon. That is real, and it is why the market filled with near-identical prompt packs within months. When production cost falls to near zero for everyone, the product stops being the differentiator.
What still costs something is knowing which specific problem a specific group of people will pay to solve. That comes from being in a niche, reading what people complain about, and building the narrow thing they asked for. A budget planner is a commodity. A budget planner for UK freelancers handling quarterly VAT is not.
The practical test before you build: can you name the person who buys this, and where they currently look for it? If not, the product is unlikely to sell regardless of how quickly AI produced it.
Which platform should you choose?
You have no audience. Etsy. You keep 88% and it brings its own search traffic. Budget for Offsite Ads eating 15% on some orders until you pass $10,000 in annual sales, at which point the rate drops to 12%.
You have an email list or social following. Gumroad, using your own links. You keep 87%, you own the customer relationship, and you avoid the 30% Discover rate entirely.
You want both. Run Etsy for discovery and Gumroad for your own audience. Nothing stops you listing the same product in both places.
You are testing an idea. Gumroad. There is no listing fee, so an experiment that fails costs you nothing but time. Etsy charges $0.20 per listing whether it sells or not.
The verdict
Digital products are a legitimate way to earn with AI, and the platform economics are better than most people assume: you keep about 88% on Etsy and 87% on Gumroad direct. The honest constraint is volume. Clearing $1,000 a month at $15 a product means 76 sales, or 2.5 every day, and most new shops take many months to get there, if they get there at all.
The caveat worth stating plainly: AI has made the build step nearly free for everyone, which means the build step no longer differentiates you. The sellers earning real money are the ones who found an underserved niche and made something specific for it. That work is not automatable, and any guide implying otherwise is selling something.
If you are starting with art rather than documents, our make money with AI art guide covers the print-on-demand routes, and how to make money with AI puts digital products alongside the other realistic options.
Related reading: how to sell AI art on Etsy and how to make money with AI art.
Fees verified against Etsy's Fees and Payments Policy and Gumroad's pricing page on 21 September 2026. Etsy payment processing varies by country; US rates used here.
Frequently Asked Questions
How much do Etsy and Gumroad take from a digital product sale?
On a $15 product, Etsy takes about $1.88 (a $0.20 listing fee, 6.5% transaction fee and payment processing), leaving you $13.12. Gumroad's direct rate is 10% plus $0.50, leaving $13.00. They are within 12 cents of each other, so fees alone are a weak reason to pick one.
How many digital products do I need to sell to make $1,000 a month?
About 76 sales a month at a $15 price point on Etsy, which is 2.5 sales every day. On Gumroad Discover, where the fee is 30%, you need 95. Raising your price is the faster lever: a $49 product needs only 22 sales a month.
Can AI make a digital product I can legally sell?
Yes, but both Etsy and Gumroad prohibit reselling raw, undirected AI output. Etsy requires that you meaningfully direct the work and disclose AI use in the listing. Also check your image generator's commercial-use terms, because several permit generation but restrict selling the output.
Is Etsy or Gumroad better for selling digital products?
Etsy if you have no audience, because it brings its own search traffic and you keep 88%. Gumroad if you have an email list or following, because you keep 87% using your own links and own the customer relationship. Avoid Gumroad Discover unless you want its traffic, as it charges 30%.
What are Etsy Offsite Ads fees on digital products?
15% of an attributed order if your shop has made under $10,000 in the past 365 days, dropping to 12% permanently once you pass that threshold. On a $15 sale that turns $13.12 take-home into $10.88. Shops under the threshold can opt out; above it, participation is mandatory.
Why do most AI-generated digital products not sell?
Because AI made production nearly free for everyone, so the product stopped being the differentiator. Near-identical prompt packs and planners flooded every marketplace. What still sells is something specific to an underserved niche, and identifying that niche is the part no tool automates.